Gamers and the general consumer electronics customers have been told for the past two years that GPUs cannot be offered at a reasonable price anymore due to unprecedented AI data center demand. Gl…
This is going viral cause it now serves a political purpose in different corners of the oligarchy.
Rubio cause he is a true believer Neocon Cold War shill(Rubio is who leaked the now disputed notion Jensen was being honeypotted by a Chinese spy) and most of the AI companies want to put a protective moat around their AI so they can cartelize the tech and it’s various inputs going into it. using the most powerful government in the world to enforce it. Nvidia was the central power agent in the middle that has an incentive in the other direction to want a more open AI market where they can sell their chips anywhere.
So deploy the China boogieman and then pressure US and US allies to refuse any adoption of China’s open weight models and restrict supply chains(something we are actively doing as we speak) and watch as the broad masses go along with new regulations and restrictions serving the AI companies interests in the name of security/safety and conservatives cheer on taking it to the Chinese and liberals cheer it on in the name of “accountability” for Trump’s corruption and punishing Nvidia for breaking (questionable) US law on sales to China…Or just cause they are distracted with the shiny drama of Jensen being the one oligarch seemingly hooking up with age appropriate women
Don’t believe me? WSJ reports Commerce is about to name a list of favored ai companies (openai, anthropic, microsoft, amazon amongst others) as “national champions.” Qualifying them for special treatment and support by the US government: faster export licenses, government backing abroad(fancy way of saying using the power and threat of US might to advance their interests), federal financing, regulatory protection, and stricter import/export controls.
I think it’s ultimately a sign of weakness(and a bit of face saving for the grifters) and I personally think China has already won this space, but there is very much still a world where the US, in a seemingly bipartisan fashion, is going to build protectionism around this tech to try and prop it up at the expense of everything else.
NVIDIA is paying customers to buy their shit (and never deploy them)
China’s humanoid robots are bought by local governments to sell training data back to the manufacturers.
While the US leaning on protectionism is a sign off weakness, so is China’s use of “Frontier models” & US chips.
I don’t think any credible analysis has China leading given their dependence on US tech, I also don’t think DeepSeek’s numbers are any more real than openAI so the idea that they are more efficient because they are cheaper is funny.
what is probably true is China is close enough that with/without protectionism that US AI companies will not be making profits big enough to justify their IPOs about time soon.
I think this fundamentally misses some important context though.
China’s goal is not to try and out compete on having the most advanced proprietary model so they can put enclosures around their tech and charge rents. Then prop up the profits of a handful of companies with elaborate circular funding schemes and gatekeeping protectionism.
China envisions AI as a open weight, widely distributable, customizable, general-purpose technology that can be integrated throughout its entire economy(and the rest of the world). The goal is to diffuse the technology as broadly as possible, drive down the cost of adoption, and build an entire industrial ecosystem around it.
And that is not the whole strategy but one component.
China’s top priority in their recent 5 year plan is not to develop the most advanced frontier model, it’s to dramatically improve and scale up the production of computer components like advanced RAM, GPU’s, and the broad hardware supply chain for AI.
Anyone that has ever messed with local LLM’s knows how intensive that is.
So on the one end you have people like Altman saying they want to take ram and gpus out of consumer’s hands, put up massive protectionism, and regulate access so they can be the feudal lords over their proprietary tech and extract rents.
On the other side is China chasing a strategy of making AI models cheaper, more accessible, and more customizable, while simultaneously investing in the domestic industrial capacity to manufacture the hardware needed to run them.
To me China is making the wiser, more holistic, and long term sustainable bet.
How does China plan to make good on this hardware? I get the notion, but it’s divorced from reality as the AI bros. Your argument rings like, China’s black hole of investment isn’t as deep as the American black hole. China could pull out of the AI boom and win by default, yet we see them trying to get into the swamp for some reason.
US AI investment last year was roughly $290 billion. China’s was $12 billion. That’s a 23 to 1 ratio. And yet the actual output is nearly identical based on Stanford HAI’s 2026 AI Index
Presumably people will need ram, motherboards, GPU’s, CPU’s, and rare earth metals even when this bubble pops, no?
AI still does have utility as we see in China with it’s incorporation into things like their factories, driverless infrastructure, academic research, military spending, and probably most important for China: assissting with their more centrally planned economy. Which all gives them a tangible competitive edge and helps grow other businesses as well.
In Shenzhen, I toured Huawei Technologies’ assembly line for its newest Mate 90 smartphones. Zha Jun, who oversees Huawei’s research and development, explained that this line used to have 86 workers per shift — doing mostly manual inspections — and the rest of the work force was robots. It recently shrank that to nine people by turning to A.I.-enabled image recognition systems.
When I asked what kind of data center it used to run the A.I. systems, Zha said: “We have no need for a data center. Huawei can get all the A.I. benefits it needs for these kinds of manufacturing improvements using our own open-weight, domain-specific A.I. models with less than one billion parameters.” Those are the ones with circuitry that amounts to the size of a small suitcase. (Parameters are a measure of the connections and weights that an A.I. model uses to process information and are used as a general proxy for its complexity and capacity to learn.) These small A.I. models, Zha added, were “good enough” to make big improvements in manufacturing.
American AI companies are trying to put enclosures around knowledge itself and charge everyone rent for access, fostering a codependency and then profiting off being it’s gatekeeper(and increasingly root themselves into government functions to extract lucrative one sided deals). This was the classic Uber/Amazon strategy of trying to debt finance your way into market monopoly to create a techno fiefdom you then have immense control over not just your direct business, but others as well. Which also means they either need to cartelize or it incentivizes a race to be the best frontier model and become the dominant player while doing this circular financing game. All for a product they can’t find profitability from as they envision and is far more problematic as a replacement for white collar work then they envisioned(now one off ramp would also be a controlled bubble demolition and bail out, which I wouldn’t rule out happening and seemingly many investors are investing based on that assumption).
Look at China in literally every other domain they have come to dominate. They build the foundation. Focus on establishing vertically integrated supply chains, build domestic manufacturing capacity usually centering critical components. Form an entire industrial ecosystem around that domain. Then they leverage industrial policy, public financing, economies of scale, and competition to drive down costs and diffuse that technology throughout the economy and then export it abroad.
When ran on a local card, on my hardware at home, it will readily admit it was created by American companies.
You can rent a card in the cloud to try it for yourself. It’s fascinating.
The Chinese only know how to copy and scale, not innovate. Innovation comes from individualistic cultures, while scaling solutions come from communal cultures. It actually makes a lot of sense philosophically.
The Americans create it and the Chinese scale it, it’s been the same story for almost a century now.
Hot beef is right. That’s a good way to
phrase it.
And before you bring it up, I’ve been experimenting with local models since GPT-J and old GAN finetunes. I have MiMo 2.6 Flash loaded right now… TBH, I’m not sure how that’s relevant.
Are all of you seriously trying to argue that local experiments with model training data ARE NOT RELEVANT to our conversation about LLMs and their training data?
Am I losing my fucking mind here or is the hive mind that strong? I’m all ears buddy.
Hot beef is literally trying to argue this point. Are you? It is actually ridiculous.
I already know how to do the things I want to do. When I don’t know how to do something I want to do, I just teach myself. It’s not that difficult.
I too would choose not to engage in semantic arguments if I found myself occupying such an untenable position; Fortunately I don’t often need to run that mental equation, being of sound mind.
After going through the process I suggested, you will see that your assumption earlier :
“You do realize that, regardless of what output an LLM gives you, it doesn’t actually know anything right? ”
Is really incorrect. You can train it on obscure and weirdly specific ideas that you came up with, and it will know about them.
How do you think a model that is unplugged from the internet knows what Disney is? At some point, that word was in the training data.
It’s that simple!
If you applied even a tiny bit of critical thinking before replying, you would have figured that out yourself. And now that I’ve seen your lack of effort, and how disingenuous your responses are, it’s mute time baby!
Yeah except that’s not how LLMs work. It has no more insight into its training data than you do into the arrangement of your own neurons. They can all be manipulated into saying pretty much anything.
Chinese only know how to copy and scale, not innovate
Implying the data can’t be extracted is actually ridiculous. It’s time for you to study a bit more. I’ve been running and training these things in my basement for years, bro.
Then stop fucking around and explain how you get it to extract data that way so we can verify your claims. Otherwise you’re not better than a flatearther who goes “just do your own research”. You made the claim so you back it up. It’s not our job to figure out what magic you did.
…LLMs don’t “know” anything about their training. Beyond (sometimes) a stock greeting intentionally finetuned in.
I’ve brought this up dozens (hundreds) of times, for years, every time someone thinks they’ve identified a stealth model or identified some clue because they’ve gotten a model to “admit” it. It’s all just blind improvisation, it’s literally what they do.
If you want a more clear example, run Deepseek in Mikupad with the raw syntax, ask it your “meta” question, look at the logprobs for the critical decision token, then continue different answers from there, and it will confidently improvise any answer because it is roleplaying.
Or you could just consider what information the model itself has access to, and realize that kind of insight is physically impossible.
Do Chinese companies have a history of skirting IP? Sure. That’s literally history.
Did Deepseek (and other Chinese companies) harvest Claude answers for training data?
Oh yes. It’s obvious. They pulled Claude absolutely shamelessly.
If you want actual proof, see papers on it, or EQBench’s “slop family tree” graphs:
But other LLM companies around the world have no leg to stand on. They all train on each other’s output, they all train on the same legally questionable data anyway.
And I reiterate:
You can’t “investigate” an LLM by asking it for information. They just make stuff up. You can get any model to say it’s training data came from anywhere with the right initial seed, and many will ape Claude or ChatGPT unprompted because they trained on so much of it across the internet.
China did to US AI companies what US AI companies did to everyone else on the planet.
Pretty sure this was largely known almost from the jump?
Deepseek’s first public model was basically just a reverse engineered ChatGPT model with modifications.
I disagree with the rest though.
The Chinese only know how to copy and scale, not innovate.
China is so far ahead of actually automating and finding practical uses for AI tech that this is absurd.
Have you looked up their dark factories or how their vehicle tech and GPS is way ahead of the US?
China, ironically, is fostering a culture and market around AI tech that the US once built it’s initial advantages with. Which was move fast, open source(including when someone doesn’t want their IP open sourced), leverage state research that can be merged into private enterprise(see Google), and foster open competition chained to a egalitarian ethos of improving lives not just profits(even if this part was always largely bullshit once companies like Google stopped promising to do no evil and became prisoners to the line must go up problem).
Versus American AI that which is increasingly organized around enclosure, proprietary control, and rent extraction.
And your embrace of open weight AI models sort of suggests why China IMO is picking the right path and why I said what I said.
Ford’s CEO calls China’s EV dominance ‘the most humbling thing I have ever seen’
Ford CEO Jim Farley said China’s EVs are “far superior” to those made in the West
https://qz.com/fords-ceo-concedes-chinas-ev-dominance
And the vehicle tech just… isn’t. The vehicles don’t pass safety standards in some countries, mostly the world’s most developed nations are the ones that don’t have Chinese cars.
In large part cause of protectionism…I literally can not buy and register and insure a Chinese vehicle in my state.
Look up China’s Vehicle–Road–Cloud Integration, that is the sort of stuff I am talking about WRT to this discussion on AI innovation.
It is a centrally planned industrial policy plan that merges BeiDou satellite navigation, connected and integrated with traffic signals, roadside sensors built into city and highway infastructure, 5G networks, cloud computing, open weight AI models, and establishes common technical standards so vehicles can communicate with their surrounding infrastructure.
Again, this is the secret sauce, not who has the individually best frontier tech in a specific domain.
No individual automaker, regardless of how innovative or well-capitalized, can independently develop the satellite networks, municipal infrastructure, communications standards, and public computing systems necessary to realize the full potential of these technologies.
And they aren’t reinventing the wheel here, this sort of managed economic planning built America, built Japan, built Taiwan, and is building China.
And what China is developing toward is to essentially then export some or all of this innovation abroad.
Honestly I don’t think most people in the USA want it like this. The network there will be more compartmentalized and corporate, like the smartphone market. Each car will have its own system.
Everything from the 80s era Toyota Camry to the 00s Ford Focus have been regulated out of existence. This is not unique to Chinese vehicles by any stretch.
This is completely valid but it’s a different issue. It’s specific to the US market and also affects all manufacturers, even domestic ones.
It also has to do with fuel economy regulations and various manufacturers ability to adapt, which then turned into - you guessed it - lobbying Congress for the current laws.
A big ol clusterfuck of corruption and production issues related to the USA, and indeed an issue, but a separate issue imo
Many in the MSM reported this over a year ago.
This is going viral cause it now serves a political purpose in different corners of the oligarchy.
Rubio cause he is a true believer Neocon Cold War shill(Rubio is who leaked the now disputed notion Jensen was being honeypotted by a Chinese spy) and most of the AI companies want to put a protective moat around their AI so they can cartelize the tech and it’s various inputs going into it. using the most powerful government in the world to enforce it. Nvidia was the central power agent in the middle that has an incentive in the other direction to want a more open AI market where they can sell their chips anywhere.
So deploy the China boogieman and then pressure US and US allies to refuse any adoption of China’s open weight models and restrict supply chains(something we are actively doing as we speak) and watch as the broad masses go along with new regulations and restrictions serving the AI companies interests in the name of security/safety and conservatives cheer on taking it to the Chinese and liberals cheer it on in the name of “accountability” for Trump’s corruption and punishing Nvidia for breaking (questionable) US law on sales to China…Or just cause they are distracted with the shiny drama of Jensen being the one oligarch seemingly hooking up with age appropriate women
Don’t believe me? WSJ reports Commerce is about to name a list of favored ai companies (openai, anthropic, microsoft, amazon amongst others) as “national champions.” Qualifying them for special treatment and support by the US government: faster export licenses, government backing abroad(fancy way of saying using the power and threat of US might to advance their interests), federal financing, regulatory protection, and stricter import/export controls.
I think it’s ultimately a sign of weakness(and a bit of face saving for the grifters) and I personally think China has already won this space, but there is very much still a world where the US, in a seemingly bipartisan fashion, is going to build protectionism around this tech to try and prop it up at the expense of everything else.
The entire AI industry is scams in scams
NVIDIA is paying customers to buy their shit (and never deploy them)
China’s humanoid robots are bought by local governments to sell training data back to the manufacturers.
While the US leaning on protectionism is a sign off weakness, so is China’s use of “Frontier models” & US chips.
I don’t think any credible analysis has China leading given their dependence on US tech, I also don’t think DeepSeek’s numbers are any more real than openAI so the idea that they are more efficient because they are cheaper is funny.
what is probably true is China is close enough that with/without protectionism that US AI companies will not be making profits big enough to justify their IPOs about time soon.
I think this fundamentally misses some important context though.
China’s goal is not to try and out compete on having the most advanced proprietary model so they can put enclosures around their tech and charge rents. Then prop up the profits of a handful of companies with elaborate circular funding schemes and gatekeeping protectionism.
China envisions AI as a open weight, widely distributable, customizable, general-purpose technology that can be integrated throughout its entire economy(and the rest of the world). The goal is to diffuse the technology as broadly as possible, drive down the cost of adoption, and build an entire industrial ecosystem around it.
And that is not the whole strategy but one component.
China’s top priority in their recent 5 year plan is not to develop the most advanced frontier model, it’s to dramatically improve and scale up the production of computer components like advanced RAM, GPU’s, and the broad hardware supply chain for AI.
Anyone that has ever messed with local LLM’s knows how intensive that is.
So on the one end you have people like Altman saying they want to take ram and gpus out of consumer’s hands, put up massive protectionism, and regulate access so they can be the feudal lords over their proprietary tech and extract rents.
On the other side is China chasing a strategy of making AI models cheaper, more accessible, and more customizable, while simultaneously investing in the domestic industrial capacity to manufacture the hardware needed to run them.
To me China is making the wiser, more holistic, and long term sustainable bet.
How does China plan to make good on this hardware? I get the notion, but it’s divorced from reality as the AI bros. Your argument rings like, China’s black hole of investment isn’t as deep as the American black hole. China could pull out of the AI boom and win by default, yet we see them trying to get into the swamp for some reason.
I don’t see it as a similar black hole
US AI investment last year was roughly $290 billion. China’s was $12 billion. That’s a 23 to 1 ratio. And yet the actual output is nearly identical based on Stanford HAI’s 2026 AI Index
Presumably people will need ram, motherboards, GPU’s, CPU’s, and rare earth metals even when this bubble pops, no?
AI still does have utility as we see in China with it’s incorporation into things like their factories, driverless infrastructure, academic research, military spending, and probably most important for China: assissting with their more centrally planned economy. Which all gives them a tangible competitive edge and helps grow other businesses as well.
American AI companies are trying to put enclosures around knowledge itself and charge everyone rent for access, fostering a codependency and then profiting off being it’s gatekeeper(and increasingly root themselves into government functions to extract lucrative one sided deals). This was the classic Uber/Amazon strategy of trying to debt finance your way into market monopoly to create a techno fiefdom you then have immense control over not just your direct business, but others as well. Which also means they either need to cartelize or it incentivizes a race to be the best frontier model and become the dominant player while doing this circular financing game. All for a product they can’t find profitability from as they envision and is far more problematic as a replacement for white collar work then they envisioned(now one off ramp would also be a controlled bubble demolition and bail out, which I wouldn’t rule out happening and seemingly many investors are investing based on that assumption).
Look at China in literally every other domain they have come to dominate. They build the foundation. Focus on establishing vertically integrated supply chains, build domestic manufacturing capacity usually centering critical components. Form an entire industrial ecosystem around that domain. Then they leverage industrial policy, public financing, economies of scale, and competition to drive down costs and diffuse that technology throughout the economy and then export it abroad.
My special interest in Dune is getting out of hand at this point.
I mean, how’d those plans within plans within plans work out for him in the end?
Still… Butlerian Jihad When?
That was over machines that think, not spicy autocomplete.
They only appeared to think.
Reverend Mother Moheim states this in the first chapter of Dune:
“But what the O.C. bible should have said is 'Thou shalt not create a machine to counterfeit a human mind.”
Sound at all familiar?
I’m ready whenever
Idk about his opinion on the outcome, but I like the way it ended for him.
Listen, I’m not saying I’d eat worm excretions to gain psychic powers in a post “AI” world, I’m just saying I wouldn’t rule it out…
I mean it extends life as well as a neat psychedelic effect. I wouldn’t like say no if offered it you know. It’s not cheap stuff
And, I mean, worst comes to worst you just become really good at piloting ships and have a steady job for life.
And you literally get to be high 24/7
I’m really trying to find the downsides and the only ones I can think of have more to do with other people, like starting wars over it or something.
Biggest downside is not having more spice.
Well put. This is the rub in essence.
Did you know that DeepSeek can be massaged into admitting where the true training data came from?
Try it out!
Guy who robbed a guy who robbed a bank very upset when he finds out he’s been robbed.
Assuming sarcasm there (my sarcasm meter isn’t great), but this drives me crazy every time it’s brought up seriously in threads.
Nope.
When ran on a local card, on my hardware at home, it will readily admit it was created by American companies.
You can rent a card in the cloud to try it for yourself. It’s fascinating.
The Chinese only know how to copy and scale, not innovate. Innovation comes from individualistic cultures, while scaling solutions come from communal cultures. It actually makes a lot of sense philosophically.
The Americans create it and the Chinese scale it, it’s been the same story for almost a century now.
You do realize that, regardless of what output an LLM gives you, it doesn’t actually know anything right?
The reason you can massage it is because it’s trying to write a plausible story for you, lmao
I think you should experiment with local models!
Train them, embed some custom things, and see what happens!
Compare the results to public services with the same prompts, etc.
As for the semantics of “knowing”, I won’t engage there 😉
“Why criticize me for having AI psychosis when you could cultivate your own?”
Hot beef is right. That’s a good way to phrase it.
And before you bring it up, I’ve been experimenting with local models since GPT-J and old GAN finetunes. I have MiMo 2.6 Flash loaded right now… TBH, I’m not sure how that’s relevant.
Are all of you seriously trying to argue that local experiments with model training data ARE NOT RELEVANT to our conversation about LLMs and their training data?
Am I losing my fucking mind here or is the hive mind that strong? I’m all ears buddy.
Hot beef is literally trying to argue this point. Are you? It is actually ridiculous.
I am not with the Lemmy hive mind consensus on LLMs, not even close. But we are discussing something more specific.
You’re not sure how at home training is relevant when we’re discussing the output of LLMs? Or home sepecifc stuff?
Home inference.
And that’s a very broad statement. But nothing we can do locally will get an LLM to intuit or reveal its own dataset.
We can get it to output Claude traces it was trained on. I am not trying to be pedantic, but the semantics/phrasing there is very important.
Why would I experiment with local models?
I already know how to do the things I want to do. When I don’t know how to do something I want to do, I just teach myself. It’s not that difficult.
I too would choose not to engage in semantic arguments if I found myself occupying such an untenable position; Fortunately I don’t often need to run that mental equation, being of sound mind.
After going through the process I suggested, you will see that your assumption earlier :
“You do realize that, regardless of what output an LLM gives you, it doesn’t actually know anything right? ”
Is really incorrect. You can train it on obscure and weirdly specific ideas that you came up with, and it will know about them.
How do you think a model that is unplugged from the internet knows what Disney is? At some point, that word was in the training data.
It’s that simple!
If you applied even a tiny bit of critical thinking before replying, you would have figured that out yourself. And now that I’ve seen your lack of effort, and how disingenuous your responses are, it’s mute time baby!
Ok, good for you!
It is
Yeah except that’s not how LLMs work. It has no more insight into its training data than you do into the arrangement of your own neurons. They can all be manipulated into saying pretty much anything.
Racist trope is racist
Implying the data can’t be extracted is actually ridiculous. It’s time for you to study a bit more. I’ve been running and training these things in my basement for years, bro.
Then stop fucking around and explain how you get it to extract data that way so we can verify your claims. Otherwise you’re not better than a flatearther who goes “just do your own research”. You made the claim so you back it up. It’s not our job to figure out what magic you did.
…LLMs don’t “know” anything about their training. Beyond (sometimes) a stock greeting intentionally finetuned in.
I’ve brought this up dozens (hundreds) of times, for years, every time someone thinks they’ve identified a stealth model or identified some clue because they’ve gotten a model to “admit” it. It’s all just blind improvisation, it’s literally what they do.
If you want a more clear example, run Deepseek in Mikupad with the raw syntax, ask it your “meta” question, look at the logprobs for the critical decision token, then continue different answers from there, and it will confidently improvise any answer because it is roleplaying.
Or you could just consider what information the model itself has access to, and realize that kind of insight is physically impossible.
Do Chinese companies have a history of skirting IP? Sure. That’s literally history.
Did Deepseek (and other Chinese companies) harvest Claude answers for training data?
Oh yes. It’s obvious. They pulled Claude absolutely shamelessly.
If you want actual proof, see papers on it, or EQBench’s “slop family tree” graphs:
https://eqbench.com/creative_writing_longform.html
But other LLM companies around the world have no leg to stand on. They all train on each other’s output, they all train on the same legally questionable data anyway.
And I reiterate:
You can’t “investigate” an LLM by asking it for information. They just make stuff up. You can get any model to say it’s training data came from anywhere with the right initial seed, and many will ape Claude or ChatGPT unprompted because they trained on so much of it across the internet.
Yeah I don’t know what the other guy is talking about, if he thinks he can “extract the data” from a LLM. Bonkers.
Wow, you think you know so much more than you do! It’s impressive!
…Okay. I don’t appreciate the mocking tone, but if you are skeptical, share your prompt, and I will try it with Deepseek locally.
You presented so many false ideas as facts that I have determined it is not worth my time to engage. Sorry!
I am not trying to overwhelm, but you challenged us to reproduce your assertion, and I can’t really do that without the prompt.
Let’s see, who should I believe? The guy actually referencing research and data or the guy going “believe me bro, I did the research”.
Hmmmm…
I’m not asking you to believe anyone. Set up the experiment yourself if you’re capable (doubt). I owe you nothing.
China did to US AI companies what US AI companies did to everyone else on the planet.
Pretty sure this was largely known almost from the jump?
Deepseek’s first public model was basically just a reverse engineered ChatGPT model with modifications.
I disagree with the rest though.
China is so far ahead of actually automating and finding practical uses for AI tech that this is absurd.
Have you looked up their dark factories or how their vehicle tech and GPS is way ahead of the US?
China, ironically, is fostering a culture and market around AI tech that the US once built it’s initial advantages with. Which was move fast, open source(including when someone doesn’t want their IP open sourced), leverage state research that can be merged into private enterprise(see Google), and foster open competition chained to a egalitarian ethos of improving lives not just profits(even if this part was always largely bullshit once companies like Google stopped promising to do no evil and became prisoners to the line must go up problem).
Versus American AI that which is increasingly organized around enclosure, proprietary control, and rent extraction.
And your embrace of open weight AI models sort of suggests why China IMO is picking the right path and why I said what I said.
Nice rebuttal, meanwhile, in reality:
China’s Dark Factories: So Automated, They Don’t Need Lights | WSJ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCBdcNA_FsI
Ford’s CEO calls China’s EV dominance ‘the most humbling thing I have ever seen’ Ford CEO Jim Farley said China’s EVs are “far superior” to those made in the West https://qz.com/fords-ceo-concedes-chinas-ev-dominance
The joke is that he was delusional and paranoid when he said it
FALGSC
Phillips and GE were the first to implement these in Alabama.
And the vehicle tech just… isn’t. The vehicles don’t pass safety standards in some countries, mostly the world’s most developed nations are the ones that don’t have Chinese cars.
In large part cause of protectionism…I literally can not buy and register and insure a Chinese vehicle in my state.
Look up China’s Vehicle–Road–Cloud Integration, that is the sort of stuff I am talking about WRT to this discussion on AI innovation.
It is a centrally planned industrial policy plan that merges BeiDou satellite navigation, connected and integrated with traffic signals, roadside sensors built into city and highway infastructure, 5G networks, cloud computing, open weight AI models, and establishes common technical standards so vehicles can communicate with their surrounding infrastructure.
Again, this is the secret sauce, not who has the individually best frontier tech in a specific domain.
No individual automaker, regardless of how innovative or well-capitalized, can independently develop the satellite networks, municipal infrastructure, communications standards, and public computing systems necessary to realize the full potential of these technologies.
And they aren’t reinventing the wheel here, this sort of managed economic planning built America, built Japan, built Taiwan, and is building China.
And what China is developing toward is to essentially then export some or all of this innovation abroad.
Honestly I don’t think most people in the USA want it like this. The network there will be more compartmentalized and corporate, like the smartphone market. Each car will have its own system.
It’s the individualistic nature.
A great number of these standards are the end result of increasingly large vehicles created and propagated by American companies.
The US has effectively created a problem of tank-sized trucks and then “fixed” the problem by mandating newer small vehicles be built like tanks.
The end result has been the functional extinction of small cars in America
Everything from the 80s era Toyota Camry to the 00s Ford Focus have been regulated out of existence. This is not unique to Chinese vehicles by any stretch.
This is completely valid but it’s a different issue. It’s specific to the US market and also affects all manufacturers, even domestic ones.
It also has to do with fuel economy regulations and various manufacturers ability to adapt, which then turned into - you guessed it - lobbying Congress for the current laws.
A big ol clusterfuck of corruption and production issues related to the USA, and indeed an issue, but a separate issue imo
Makes sense but Google is the only company that makes a model that can run on an affordable GPU and obtain frontier intelligence.
Some of your points are valid and some not so much. But yes the Chinese will always be better at certain things, and the Americans too